A race between two Flathead County district court judges has put a long-running question at the center of Montana's 2026 Supreme Court election: what does "nonpartisan" actually mean when party money is flowing into a judicial campaign?

What this means for you
Montana:The Montana Supreme Court is the state's court of last resort on constitutional questions affecting property rights, water law, land use, and criminal procedure — the outcome of this race shapes the court's ideological balance for years. Both candidates are from Flathead County, and the debate over partisan money in nominally nonpartisan judicial elections is playing out statewide.
Flathead County:Both candidates — Eddy and Wilson — currently serve as district court judges in Flathead County, making this a home-county race with unusual local prominence.
Watch next:Election Day is November 3, 2026. The seat is on the statewide general election ballot.

Amy Eddy, 50, and Dan Wilson, 60, are competing for the seat being vacated by retiring Justice Beth Baker. Both candidates registered as nonpartisan. Both say they want to keep politics out of the courtroom. But their approaches diverge sharply when it comes to accepting partisan support.

**Eddy: No party money, no party forums**

Eddy has drawn a hard line. She has refused endorsements, donations, and support from both the Democratic and Republican parties, and she won't appear at party-sponsored forums or speak at party-affiliated events.

"That's really the definition of nonpartisan," Eddy said. "You do not associate yourself with the political parties, you don't run under a political party label. It's not a very high bar. We have not wanted our judges to be held captive by political parties."

Eddy was appointed to the 11th Judicial Circuit bench in 2015 by then-Gov. Steve Bullock and has been re-elected twice. She has heard hundreds of cases in Flathead County, including many tied to asbestos contamination in Libby.

She has received endorsements from eight current and retired state Supreme Court justices, including sitting Justices Katherine Bidegary and Ingrid Gustafson. Eddy called the judicial support "almost overwhelming."

Political scientist Jessi Bennion, however, noted that several left-leaning organizations have backed Eddy's candidacy even without her formal acceptance — among them Forward Montana, the Montana ACLU, and Wild Montana, groups that typically align with Democratic candidates.

**Wilson: Republican money, constitutional conservative label**

Wilson acknowledges receiving $20,000 from the state Republican Party and an $11,000 donation from the Park County Republican Central Committee, but maintains his goal of serving as a nonpartisan justice.

A fourth-generation Montanan, Wilson describes himself as a "constitutional conservative" — a label he says reflects a judicial philosophy, not a party affiliation. He ran for the Montana Supreme Court in 2024, losing to Justice Bidegary by eight points.

University of Montana political science professor Rob Saldin said that prior campaign may actually benefit Wilson. Name recognition from the 2024 race could draw votes from familiarity, Saldin said, even without a formal party label on the ballot.

Saldin also offered broader context for why partisan dynamics are shaping what is nominally a nonpartisan race. As Montana has shifted into reliably Republican territory, he said, Republican-aligned groups have grown more willing — and more strategic — about making their preferences clear in judicial contests.

"For a long time, it was less clear that making a judicial race line up along partisan lines would be a significant advantage to one candidate or the other," Saldin said. "But as Montana has become more and more clearly Republican, I think Republicans, probably rightly so, see an advantage to making it clear to voters which candidate the party is supporting."

On the other side of the ledger, Bennion noted the Montana Chamber of Commerce is among the organizations backing Wilson.

**What's at stake**

The Montana Supreme Court is the final word on state constitutional questions — land use, water rights, criminal procedure, property rights — that land squarely in the everyday lives of Montana ranchers, landowners, and small-business owners. Whether the court's next justice arrives with closer ties to a party apparatus or a stricter arm's-length posture toward both parties is a live question this election will settle.

Eddy, if elected, would serve alongside Bidegary and Gustafson, both of whom have endorsed her. Wilson's 2024 opponent, Bidegary, would be a colleague if he prevails.

*The Daily Interlake and the Community News Service at the University of Montana School of Journalism contributed reporting to this item. The article as received was truncated; Wilson's full self-description was not available in the source material.*