HELENA — Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen announced Friday he will not defend Initiative 194 in federal court, saying the voter-approved measure on corporate political spending plainly violates the First Amendment.

What this means for you
Montana:Montana voters approved I-194 by a wide margin this month, but the measure now faces consolidated federal litigation and will be defended in court by its ballot-initiative backers rather than the state's own attorney general — leaving Montanans who supported it reliant on a nonprofit group to argue their case.
Local:No direct county- or city-level effect identified.
Watch next:No federal court hearing dates have been scheduled yet in the consolidated case; watch for a scheduling order from the U.S. District Court.

Knudsen filed the notice in federal court, citing the U.S. Supreme Court's decisions in *First National Bank v. Bellotti* and *Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission* as the basis for his position. "This is consistent with the Attorney General's prior legal position when evaluating similar proposals that restrict the political speech for entities with corporate charters," the filing states.

Despite refusing to defend the law, Knudsen said his office will enforce I-194 "until the judicial branch can render a decision in this matter."

I-194, also known as "the Montana Plan," passed this month with roughly 66 percent of the vote — more than 307,000 votes in favor. The measure was designed as a direct challenge to the Supreme Court's 2010 *Citizens United* ruling. Its supporters argue that states retain authority to define the powers of "artificial persons" such as corporations, unions, and nonprofits, and that states can exclude from those powers the ability to spend money in elections.

The Transparent Election Initiative, the group that introduced I-194, said it would step in to defend the law in court. "Two-thirds of Montanans voted to end corporate and dark money spending in our elections," said TEI founder and president Jeff Mangan. "But the Attorney General has decided that the will of the people — the voices of real Montanans — simply doesn't matter. We won't stand for it."

Two separate federal lawsuits have already been filed against the measure. The first came from the Frontier Institute, the Montana Republican Party, and the Montana Family Foundation. A second challenge was brought by a coalition of business groups including the Montana Chamber of Commerce, the Billings and Kalispell Chambers of Commerce, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

The business plaintiffs argued I-194 is already producing "immediate and severe chilling effects" on their ability to engage in political speech and plan for upcoming election cycles, calling it "targeted speech suppression" against businesses. "Montana has no legitimate interest in suppressing political speech to equalize the relative voices of speakers," their attorneys wrote.

The two cases have since been consolidated into a single federal proceeding. As of Monday, no hearing dates had been scheduled, according to KTVH, which first reported the story.