By Henry Kriegel
A Tale of Two Visions
As America celebrates its 250th birthday, a ~~CNBC/Generation Lab poll~~ found that nearly half of Americans ages 18 to 34 view democratic socialism favorably. That tells us people are hurting in today's economy, and too few have heard the case for the system that made this the freest, most prosperous nation in history. It's time we made that case.
We face two distinct visions. One holds that ordinary people are capable of extraordinary things; the other, that government knows best. The first rests on the founders' conviction that each of us is endowed by our Creator with inalienable rights, and with gifts and talents of our own. A free market rewards those who develop their talents to meet the real needs of others. The second sounds nice and insists that government must provide life's basics. One path leads to ingenuity and self-improvement, the other to dependency and decay.
None of this means ignoring today's struggles. Rent is too high, groceries cost too much, and too many young people feel shut out of the American Dream and home ownership. Those frustrations are real, but the debate isn't whether America has problems, but how we fix them. Our system lets us make necessary changes without sacrificing our rights as free people. Socialism, by contrast, doesn't see a country with problems to fix; it sees a rotten foundation to dismantle. The answer to America's challenges has never been less freedom. The answer has been more freedom to build, innovate, and compete.
Housing shows the difference clearly. ~~Decades of government-run housing~~ in our largest cities have left crumbling projects where broken elevators, mold and leaking roofs are left unrepaired for years. When government owns the building or caps the rent, no one has much reason to repair, upgrade or build anything new, and the housing shortage only deepens. The fix is to cut the zoning restrictions, permitting delays and red tape that keep homes from being built, and let supply catch up with demand.
Healthcare follows the same pattern. Socialized medicine promises "free" care, but it puts the government between you and your doctor. Your choice of physician narrows to whoever the system can offer. Government protocols, not your doctor's judgment, dictate which treatments you receive. Then comes the wait. In Canada, the median wait from referral to treatment now tops 28 weeks, and <u>England's hospital</u> waiting list exceeds 7 million cases. Delayed care means worse outcomes, and Britain trails the United States in <u>survival rates for several major cancers</u>. Healthcare should be personal. Health Savings Accounts put patients in charge, letting them choose the doctor they trust at a price they can afford, with money that stays theirs.
Even groceries aren't immune. ~~New York City~~ is moving to open <u>city-run grocery stores</u> that neither pay rent nor property taxes, competing against family grocers who pay both. That isn't competition; it's using taxpayer money to undercut the store down the block. Politicians should look to ease the mandates and regulations that drive up prices on every shelf.
Abroad, the record is even starker. Venezuela, once the envy of South America, seized control of its oil industry and watched output collapse by more than two-thirds, while nearly ~~eight million people~~ fled. <u>Cuba's aging, state-run power grid</u> has collapsed nationwide six times this year alone, and satellite photos of North Korea at night show a black void broken only by the lights of Pyongyang. Worst of all, last century's communist regimes were responsible for an <u>estimated 85 million to 100 million deaths</u>, according to *The Black Book of Communism*.
Defending free markets does not mean defending crony capitalism, where the politically connected are rewarded. When government picks winners, like mandating electric vehicles on an unready market, it stifles innovation and raises costs.
This isn't about left versus right. It's a simpler question: Do we trust free people, or a few people at the top who think they can run your life better than you can?
We owe our young people a clear answer. That means supporting free markets, lower and flatter taxes, education freedom, fewer regulations and an end to fraud and abuse, rather than surrendering our freedom to a government controlled by the few. Let's bet on free people, every time.
*Henry Kriegel is the Deputy State Director of Americans for Prosperity-Montana.*
# **Sources (for **editor**, **not for print publication**)**
Poll: CNBC/Generation Lab survey of 1,088 Americans ages 18–34, Aug. 2026: 46% favorable toward democratic socialism, 23% unfavorable. https://www.denver7.com/news/politics/real-talk-democratic-socialism-is-growing-in-popularity-among-young-americans
Public housing: NYCHA's 2023 Physical Needs Assessment puts its 20-year repair backlog at $78.3 billion; the agency acknowledges residents regularly face mold, leaks and heat and hot-water failures. https://www.6sqft.com/nycha-says-it-needs-nearly-80-billion-for-repairs/ ; https://www.nyc.gov/assets/nycha/downloads/pdf/stapleton-english.pdf
Canada wait times: Fraser Institute, Waiting Your Turn 2025: median 28.6 weeks from GP referral to treatment (also cited in AFP Fight Socialism playbook). https://www.fraserinstitute.org/studies/waiting-your-turn-wait-times-for-health-care-in-canada-2025
England waiting list: NHS England referral-to-treatment data, May 2026: about 7.3 million cases (roughly 6.2 million individual patients). https://healthcareandprotection.com/nhs-waiting-list-climbs-back-to-7-3-million/
Cancer survival: CONCORD-3 study, The Lancet, 2018: U.S. among eight countries with consistently high survival for most cancers; U.K. lower than comparable countries for several common cancers. https://www.auntminnie.com/industry-news/article/15619543/lancet-cancer-survival-rates-improve-but-vary-widely
NYC grocery stores: Mayor Mamdani's plan, announced April 2026; the city owns the site, covers rent and construction, and waives real estate taxes (also cited in AFP playbook). https://bronx.news12.com/mayor-mamdani-unveils-location-of-nycs-first-city-run-grocery-store ; https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/4526221/zohran-mamdani-nyc-first-city-run-grocery-store-100-day-address/
Venezuela oil: output fell about 70%, from 3.1 million barrels a day in 2005 to 0.9 million in 2024 (American Petroleum Institute; also cited in AFP playbook).
https://www.api.org/energy-insights/charts-analysis/venezuela-production-has-fallen-70-percent
Venezuelan exodus: UNHCR Global Appeal 2026: nearly 7.9 million Venezuelan refugees and migrants living abroad. https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/2025-12/Venezuela%20situation%20overview%20-%20Global%20Appeal%202026.pdf
Cuba: sixth nationwide grid collapse of 2026 on Aug. 2 (WPLG Local 10). https://www.local10.com/news/world/2026/08/03/cuba-begins-restoring-power-after-sixth-nationwide-electrical-grid-collapse-of-2026/
Communism death toll: Stéphane Courtois et al., The Black Book of Communism (Harvard University Press, 1999), estimate of 85–100 million deaths. https://www.publishersweekly.com/9780674076082