Montana voters will decide Nov. 3 whether to ban corporate contributions from state elections under Initiative 194, also called The Montana Plan — a measure with rare bipartisan backing that has nonetheless drawn fierce opposition from the state's major business groups.
The initiative would prohibit "artificial persons" — corporations and other business entities — from contributing "anything of value" to candidates, political parties, or ballot campaigns. Its architect is Jeff Mangan, a former Montana Commissioner of Political Practices who founded the Transparent Election Initiative, the nonprofit backing the measure.
Mangan designed I-194 to carve out a state-level exception to the U.S. Supreme Court's 2010 Citizens United ruling, which held that the government cannot restrict corporate political spending. That decision was later used to strike down Montana's own century-old corporate contribution ban in 2012.
Former Republican Gov. Marc Racicot, former Democratic Gov. Steve Bullock, and former U.S. Sen. Jon Tester have all signed on as supporters — an unusual alignment across party lines. Mangan has framed the measure as a way to "put Montanans back in charge of Montana elections."
**Business groups push back**
The Montana Chamber of Commerce and its Billings and Kalispell counterparts have opposed The Montana Plan since it was introduced, arguing that as written, it would silence Montana businesses while leaving the door open to out-of-state money.
Lorraine Clarno, CEO of the Kalispell Chamber of Commerce, said she supports keeping dark and out-of-state money out of elections — but that I-194 sweeps too broadly, making no distinction between large corporate donors and local civic institutions.
"Lawyers are already arguing on both sides of this and that tells us it's not well-written and that's why we're against it," Clarno told the Flathead Beacon. "We don't want to lose our voice."
Clarno said the chamber has used its organizational weight to help pass local measures that struggled on their own — a school levy that hadn't passed in 18 years, a county detention center bond, and an emergency responders levy for the City of Kalispell. Under I-194, she said, the chamber would be prohibited from hosting candidate forums or partnering with local agencies on those kinds of campaigns.
Proponents counter that chambers of commerce could still engage in local campaigns — they would simply be required to disclose that involvement clearly, as they did before Citizens United. Mangan's backers argue the transparency requirement is the whole point.
**Flathead business owners split**
Not every Flathead Valley business owner sees the initiative as a threat. Ed Docter, who owns the Montana Tap House in Whitefish and hosts the Beers, Buds and the Big Sky podcast, offered a blunt endorsement.
"I'm a small business owner and I cannot stand all the mailers and commercials," Docter said. "The people that are against it, I am completely against. If big corporations are against it, then I am for it."
Helen Weems, a family nurse practitioner and abortion provider at All Families Healthcare in Whitefish, supports The Montana Plan on accountability grounds.
"I want our politicians to be accountable to Montanans and individual voters, and that especially shows up in healthcare," Weems said. "It's a huge industry and we do not need our elected officials paying homage to corporations."
**What comes next**
Whether I-194 could survive a post-election legal challenge is an open question even among its supporters. Citizens United remains controlling federal precedent, and any Montana statute or constitutional amendment that conflicts with it faces a probable court fight. Opponents have signaled they would pursue legal challenges if the measure passes.
Ballots were mailed to absentee voters Oct. 9. Voters can check registration status and ballot status at voterportal.mt.gov.