> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.the406.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Two Flathead Judges Square Off Over What 'Nonpartisan' Really Means in Montana Supreme Court Race
- URL: https://www.the406.news/two-flathead-judges-square-off-over-what-nonpartisan-really-means-in-montana-supreme-court-race/
- Published: 2026-10-26T13:52:41.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-26T13:52:41.000Z
- Description: Amy Eddy and Dan Wilson are both running on judicial independence — but one has taken $31,000 from Republican party committees while the other has refused all party money and endorsements.
- Author: Samuel Von Worthington
- Tags: Courts, elections, #zone-kalispell, #zone-statewide, #type-court-docket, #ai-assisted, #bridger-edit, #dedupe-cf8aae4592263219

A long-running debate over politics and Montana's courts has taken center stage in this year's Montana Supreme Court race, where two Flathead County judges are competing to replace retiring Justice Beth Baker — and arguing over what "nonpartisan" actually means.

What this means for you

Montana:The Montana Supreme Court race directly shapes the state's highest judicial body for years to come — affecting rulings on everything from water rights and public lands to criminal appeals and constitutional challenges. The seat being contested is currently open due to Justice Beth Baker's retirement.

Flathead County:Both candidates are sitting Flathead County district court judges, making this a rare instance where the county sends a judge to the state's highest court regardless of which candidate wins.

Watch next:Election Day is November 3, 2026\. The race appears on the statewide ballot as a nonpartisan judicial contest.

Both candidates, Amy Eddy and Dan Wilson, registered as nonpartisan for the race. Both say they want to keep politics out of the courtroom. But their approaches to that goal look very different on paper.

\*\*Eddy: No party money, no party forums\*\*

Eddy, 50, has drawn a hard line. She has refused endorsements, donations, and support from both the Montana Democratic and Republican parties, and says she will not appear at party-sponsored forums or speak at party-affiliated events.

"That's really the definition of nonpartisan," Eddy said. "You do not associate yourself with the political parties, you don't run under a political party label. It's not a very high bar. We have not wanted our judges to be held captive by political parties."

Eddy began her legal career in private practice, where she said she developed a firsthand understanding of how the Supreme Court functions from the litigant's side. Former Gov. Steve Bullock appointed her as a district court judge in the 11th Judicial Circuit in 2015; she has been re-elected twice since. On the Flathead County bench, she has heard hundreds of cases, including a substantial number of asbestos-related cases stemming from the Libby contamination.

She has drawn endorsements from two sitting justices — Katherine Bidegary and Ingrid Gustafson — as well as six retired justices. Bidegary notably defeated Wilson in the 2024 Supreme Court race.

Political scientist Jessi Bennion, however, pointed out that several left-leaning organizations have backed Eddy's candidacy, even without her formal blessing. "If you look at Amy Eddy, she's supported by Forward Montana, the Montana ACLU, Wild Montana — organizations that typically support Democratic candidates," Bennion said. Eddy has not solicited or accepted those groups' formal support, but their alignment with her campaign is visible.

\*\*Wilson: Party dollars, independent judgment\*\*

Wilson, 60, maintains he will be a nonpartisan justice despite receiving $20,000 from the Montana Republican Party and $11,000 from the Park County Republican Central Committee — a combined $31,000 in party money. He has also drawn support from the Montana Chamber of Commerce and other organizations that typically back Republican candidates.

This is Wilson's second run at the Supreme Court. He ran for a different seat in 2024 and lost to Justice Bidegary by eight points. University of Montana political science professor Rob Saldin said that loss may paradoxically benefit Wilson this cycle: name recognition from the 2024 race could translate into votes from familiarity, even among voters who don't follow judicial races closely.

\*\*The broader trend\*\*

Saldin framed the candidates' divergence as part of a statewide shift. Partisan backing in formally nonpartisan judicial elections has intensified in recent years, he said, tracking Montana's increasingly Republican voting pattern.

"For a long time, it was less clear that making a judicial race line up along partisan lines would be a significant advantage to one candidate or the other," Saldin said. "But as Montana has become more and more clearly Republican, I think Republicans, probably rightly so, see an advantage to making it clear to voters which candidate the party is supporting."

Eddy put it in sharper terms: "We're in a time where Montanans really deserve to maintain a fair and independent court as an independent branch, not as an extension of one of the political parties."

The seat is open because Justice Beth Baker is retiring. Whoever wins will join a court that already includes Bidegary and Gustafson, both of whom have endorsed Eddy.

\*This article is based on reporting by Elle Daniel of the Community News Service, UM School of Journalism, as published by the Daily Inter-Lake and Hagadone News Network. The406.news has not independently conducted interviews for this piece; all quotes are drawn from that reporting.\*

Source: [https://hagadonenewsnetwork.com/news/2026/oct/25/candidates-differ-over-meaning-of-a-nonpartisan-montana-supreme-court/](https://hagadonenewsnetwork.com/news/2026/oct/25/candidates-differ-over-meaning-of-a-nonpartisan-montana-supreme-court/?ref=the406.news)